| 1 | Bob Boston | Jamestown Appila (1983-1985, 1988-1990), Kadina (1986-1987), Warnertown (1994-1995), Port (1996-2005), Southern Flinders (2006), Solomontown (1978-1981, 2009-2011). (Port (Bulldogs)) | 28 |
| 2 | Barry Pilmore | Noarlunga (1988-1993, 1997-1998, 2016-2017), Reynella (2001), Willunga (2003-2014). | 23 |
| 3 | Trevor Potts | Pinnaroo (1974-1975), Christies Beach (1983-1984), Plympton (1987-1989), Bridgewater (1994), Blackwood (1995-1996), Kangarilla (2000), Morphett Vale (2001-2005), Hahndorf (2010-2013). | 21 |
| Warren Schenke | Jervois (1966-1972), Imperial – RMFL (1974-1981), Redlegs (1983-1988). (Murray Bridge Redlegs, Imperial (RM)) | 21 |
| 5 | Rob Head | Roopena (1982-1984, 1988-1996, 2013-2014), Morphett Vale (1999-2001), Mount Lofty (2002-2004). | 20 |
| Kevin Lane | Burra (1957-1960), Aberdeen (1961-1965), North Clare (1976-1977, 1981- 1983, 1985-1986), Booborowie Hallett (1978-1979), Blyth Snowtown (1991-1992). (Burra FC) | 20 |
| 7 | Brian Smith | Booleroo Centre (1988-1990), BMW (1992-1993), Gladstone Combine (1996-1998), Blyth Snowtown (2000-2005), BSR (2008-2010), Jamestown Peterborough (2012-2013). (BSR Tigers, BMW Lions) | 19 |
| 8 | Russell Sawford | Weeroona Bay (1996-2004), West Whyalla (2007-2015). | 18 |
| 9 | Russell Kupsch | Crystal Brook (1966-1970, 1974-1982, 1986), Risdon (1987-1988). | 17 |
| Ken Burton | Central Whyalla (1988-1991, 1997-2007, 2010-2011). | 17 |
| Phil Muhovics | Glencoe (1987-1988), Robe (1991), Nangwarry (1993-1998, 2004-2007), East Gambier (1999-2002). | 17 |
| Richard Hill | Onkaparinga Valley (1978), Port MacDonnell (1979), Millicent (1983- 1986), Hahndorf (1988-1995, 1997-1999). | 17 |
| Roger Nettle | Mount Compass (1971-1973), Border Districts (1974-1977), Kingston (1978-1979), Kybybolite (1980-1982), Cobdogla (1983-1984), Berri (1970, 1990-1991). (Kingston (SE)) | 17 |
| 14 | John Murphy | Barmera Monash (1957-1958), Eudunda (1959-1962, 1966, 1969), Renmark (1975-1980), Loxton (1982), Berri (1983). (Renmark Rovers) | 16 |
| Stephen Keam | Aldinga (1988-1993), Reynella (1994-2000), Marion (2011-2013), Happy Valley (2015). | 16 |
| Steve Lubcke | Kingscote (1981-1983), Barossa Districts (2000-2002), Tanunda (2008- 2011), Mallala (2012-2017). | 16 |
| 17 | John McInerney | West Whyalla (1957-1961, 1966-1975). | 15 |
| Kevin Duffy | Orroroo (1968-1973, 1976-1980, 1987-1990). | 15 |
| Norm Davis | Riverton (1954-1959, 1974), RSMU (1976-1980), Gawler Central (1981- 1982), Kapunda (1983). (RSMU Hawks) | 15 |
| Garry Attrill | Jervois (1975-1977, 1994-1995), Meningie (1978-1980), Tailem Bend (1988-1991), Rambler (1997-1999). (Rambler (RM)) | 15 |
| Tony Fielke | Imperial – RMFL (2002-2010), Nairne Bremer (2012-2017). (Nairne Bremer United, Imperial (RM)) | 15 |
| Terry Eleftheriadis | Lyrup (1993), Cobdogla (1996-1998), Barmera Monash (2009-2010), Loxton North (2003-2004, 2006-2008), Berri (2014-2017) | 15 |
| 23 | Vernon Meuller | Birdwood (1957-1968, 1971-1972). | 14 |
| Brenton Lamshed | Tumby Bay (1979-1981), South Whyalla (1987-1988), West Whyalla (1995- 1997), Kadina (1998-2001), Bute (2003-2004). | 14 |
| Brad Richardson | Padthaway (2004-2006), Naracoorte (2007-2010), Keith (2011-2016), Kingston (2017). (Kingston (SE)) | 14 |
| Lynton Bishop | Yankalilla (1987-1988), Willunga (1997-2000), Strathalbyn (2002-2004), Encounter Bay (2005-2006), Morphett Vale (2009-2011). | 14 |
| Bohdan Cybulka | Tailem Bend (1972-1973), Rambler – RMFL (1975-1984, 1990-1991). (Rambler (RM)) | 14 |
| Ian Stafford | Nuriootpa (1994-2003, 2009-2010), Mallala (2004), North Gambier (2007). (Nuriootpa Rovers, North Gambier FC) | 14 |
| 29 | Ian Westbrook | Arthurton (1980-1982, 1988), Wallaroo (1983-1984), Paskeville (1985- 1986), Bute (1990-1993), CY Cougars (1997). (Central Yorke Cougars) | 13 |
| Peter Vivian | Angaston (1988-1991), Gawler Central (1998-2006). | 13 |
| Erwin 'Boyce' Ross | Ngallo (1930-1935, 1947-1953). | 13 |
| Lloyd Tugwell | Victor Harbor (1948-1952, 1968), Encounter Bay (1958-1963), Yankalilla (1955). | 13 |
| Jim Lihou | Victor Harbor (1985-1991), Onkaparinga Valley (1993-1996), Goolwa Port Elliot (2005-2006). | 13 |
| Tim Richards | Meningie (1999-2002), Jervois (2004-2007), Kingston (2010-2014). (Kingston (SE)) | 13 |
| David Freeman | BMW (2004-2006), North Whyalla (2008-2013), South Whyalla (2014- 2017) (BMW Lions) | 13 |
| Craig Griffiths | Waikerie (1995-1997, 2000-2001, 2003-2005, 2012-2013), Tanunda (2015- 2017) | 13 |
| 37 | Max Horne | South Whyalla (1950), South Broken Hill (1952-1955), Port Neill (1956- 1958, 1963), Lincoln South (1968-1970). | 12 |
| Graeme Fargher | West Whyalla (1981-1988), Wayback – PLFL (1977-1980). (Wayback (PL)) | 12 |
| Doug Laube | Solomontown (1931-1934, 1936, 1938-1941, 1943-1945). | 12 |
| Ian Willmott | Warramboo (1982-1988), Central Eyre (1999-2002). | 12 |
| John Dunstan | Brinkworth (1970-1971), Arno Bay (1973-1975), Darke Peak (1977-1978, 1981), Kimba Districts (1989), Rudall (1999-2001). | 12 |
| Steve Samuels | Murrayville (2003-2005), Mount Compass (2006-2010), Mount Barker (2011-2014). | 12 |
| David Bennett | Yankalilla (1974-1975), Border Districts (1978-1981, 1983-1984, 1994), Mundulla (1988-1991). | 12 |
| Paul Crate | Loxton (1985), Loxton North (1986-1987), Willunga (2001-2002), McLaren Vale (1990-1992), Christies Beach (2012-2015). | 12 |
| Todd Butler | Encounter Bay (2004, 2015-2017), Keith (2006-2009), Border Downs Tintinara (2010-2013). | 12 |
| Keith Ransom | Kalangadoo (1988-1989), Tarpeena (1993), Heywood (2007-2009), West Gambier (2010-2013), Glencoe (2015-2016). | 12 |
| 47 | Greg Germein | Minlaton (1973-1975), Curramulka (1976-1977), Stansbury (1978, 1983- 1984), Southern Eagles (1995), CMS Crows (1997-1999). | 11 |
| Doug Matchett | West Whyalla (1969-1973, 1983-1984), Roopena (1974-1976), North Whyalla (1979). | 11 |
| John McBain | Naracoorte (1963-1965), Penola (1966-1967), Edenhope (1968-1973). | 11 |
| Peter Sims | Kongorong (1989), South Gambier (1990-1999). | 11 |
| Don McSweeny | Cummins (1970-1974), United Yeelanna (1975-1980). | 11 |
| Doug Tugwell | Victor Harbor (1953-1957, 1962), Encounter Bay (1964-1967, 1971). | 11 |
| Barry Stringer | Brinkworth Yacka (1984), Brinkworth Yacka Spalding (1985-1986), Brinkworth Spalding Redhill (1987-1994). (BSR Tigers) | 11 |
| Terry Fisher | Berri (1980-1982), Barmera Monash (1987-1988, 1994-1995), Loxton North (1989-1990). | 11 |
| John Hammer | Minnipa (1977), Peake & District (1979-1982), Lameroo South (1983- 1984), Kapinnie (1991), Wudinna United (1996), Western United (1997- 1998). (Peake & District FC, Western United (FW)) | 11 |
| Mark Pittman | Freeling (1990-1991), Tanunda (1999-2000), Kapunda (2001-2007). | 11 |
| Roger Doody | Kalangadoo (1981-1985, 1992-1993), (West Gambier 1986-1989). | 11 |
| Grant Russell | Mount Lofty (1997), West Gambier (2004-2006), Berri (2007-2009), Hamilton (2009-2010), Balaklava (2013-2014). | 11 |
| George Martin | Jervois (1930-1940) | 11 |
| Wally Dittmar | Penola (1955-1958), Millicent (1964), Loxton (1967), Wirrulla (1968- 1972). | 11 |
| Mick Duncan | O'Sullivan Beach (1996-1997), Marion (1999-2001), Nairne (2005-2007), RSMU (2010-2011), Echunga (2017). (O’Sullivan Beach, Nairne Bremer United, RSMU Hawks) | 11 |
| Tony Burgess | Marion (1993-1998), Strathalbyn (2012-2016). | 11 |
| Brett James | Kersbrook (2007-2017) | 11 |
| 64 | Trevor Jenkin | Lobethal (1990-1991), Nairne Bremer (2001-2002), Birdwood (2006- 2009), Meadows (2014-2015). (Nairne Bremer United) | 10 |
| Kevin McSporran | West Augusta (1985-1992), Quorn Wolves (1993-1994). | 10 |
| Andrew Bromley | Kongorong (1990-1992), East Gambier (1993-1995), Tantanoola (1996- 1999). | 10 |
| Royl Chardon | Stirling (1946-1947, 1953-1960). | 10 |
| Steve O'Connor | Willaston (2002-2004, 2013-2015), Barossa District (2005-2007), Goolwa Port Elliot (2011). (Barossa Districts) | 10 |
| Don Lade | Wisanger (1971-1974, 1976, 1979, 1996), Western Districts (1987-1989). (Western Districts (KI)) | 10 |
| Allan Goldfinch | Loxton (1963-1965, 1968-1971), South Whyalla (1972-1973), Christies Beach (1977). | 10 |
| Ken Follett | Langhorne Creek (1962-1963, 1965, 1971-1973), Strathalbyn (1966), Goolwa (1967-1970). | 10 |
| Wayne Johnson | Hatherleigh (1971), Victor Harbor (1972-1974), Goolwa (1975-1976, 1978-1981). | 10 |
| Doug Koch | Parilla (1976-1985). | 10 |
| Jay Tape | Edithburgh (1963-1965, 1968-1972, 1975), Yorketown (1966). | 10 |
| Rodney Maynard | Lameroo (1999-2002, 2005-2007, 2014-2016). | 10 |
| Ben Coleman | Mount Lofty (2008-2011), Morphett Vale (2012-2015), Happy Valley (2016-2017). | 10 |
| Mick Redden | Orroroo (1994-1998), Jamestown Peterborough (2004, 2013-2016). | 10 |
| Ashley Barnett | Tantanoola (1993-1994), Kingston (1996-1997), Goolwa Port Elliot (2001- 2002), Callington (2007-2008), Hamley Bridge (2012-2013) (Callington United Eagles, Kingston (SE)) | 10 |
| Peter Beard | Lock (1986, 1988, 1990, 1993-1995, 2004-2005), Elliston (1999-2000) | 10 |
| Don Guerin | Wunkar (1963-1964), Waikerie (1966-1967, 1971-1972), Jervois (1981- 1982), McLaren Flat (1968, 1970). | 10 |
| 81 | Damien Prentis | Central Augusta (1991-1996, 2006-2007), West Augusta (2002). | 9 |
| Dean Woosnam | Naracoorte (2003-2006, 2011-2014), Border Districts (2010). | 9 |
| Garry Kernahan | South Augusta (2001-08). | 9 |
| Pat Hynes | South Augusta (1978-1979, 1986, 1991-1996). | 9 |
| Barry Tyrrell | Barmera Monash (1982-1988, 1992-1993). | 9 |
| Norman Catford | Parrakie (1923-1931). | 9 |
| Lyndon Prior | Two Wells (1992-1993), Crystal Brook (1998-1999), Port Pirie Lions (2000-2002), Southern Flinders (2007-2008). | 9 |
| Bronte Payne | Peake (1964, 1967-1969, 1971-1974), Peake & District (1978). (Peake & District FC) | 9 |
| George Skipworth | Arthurton (1948-1954, 1957-1958). | 9 |
| Alan Stringer | North Clare (1991-1992, 1994-1995), Happy Valley (2002-2005), Cove (2011). | 9 |
| Peter Green | Mount Torrens (1987), Ardrossan (1991-1992), Arthurton (1993-1994), Southern Eagles (2007-2010). | 9 |
| Robert Reu | Imperial – RMFL (1966-1969, 1971, 1981-1982, 1986-1987). | 9 |
| Trevor Vowels | Orroroo (1981-1984), Roopena (1985-1987), Lucindale (1990-1991). | 9 |
| Malcolm McGrath | South Gawler (1990-1993), Angaston (1996-2000). | 9 |
| Peter Kitschke | Jamestown (1964-1966, 1968-1971, 1975), Jamestown Appila (1982). | 9 |
| Lester Ross | Padthaway (1993-1995), Casterton (1996-1997), Southern Eagles (1998), Barmera Monash (1999-2001). | 9 |
| Barry Moore | Ceduna (1964), Brinkworth (1969-1970), Border Downs (1973-1974, 1981- 1983, 1992). | 9 |
| Eddie Dickinson | Mundulla (1963-1965), Bordertown (1961, 1975-1978, 1981). | 9 |
| Adrian Higgins | Tumby Bay (1985-1988, 1992, 2001), Lincoln South (2000-2002). | 9 |
| David Earl | McLaren Flat (1986-1987, 1992-1993), Reynella (2009-2011), Cove (2014- 2015). | 9 |
| Ray Whitaker | Kybybolite (1954-1957), Lucindale (1959-1960), Works (1962-1964). | 9 |
| Mark Seelander | Angaston (2001-2006), Willaston (2009-2010), BBH (2014). (BBH Rams) | 9 |
| Gary Gurney | Kybybolite (1966-1968), Casterton (1969-1971), Apsley (1977). | 9 |
| Trevor Sims | Broughton Mundoora (1984-1989, 2014), Crystal Brook (2001-2003). | 9 |
| Gary Peach | Tailem Bend (1992-1993, 1995-1999, 2016-2017). | 9 |
| Peter Sinclair | Lincoln South (1976-1977), Kapinnie (1983-1984, 1987), Boston (1988-1989), Cummins Ramblers (1992-1993). | 9 |
| Scott Brand | Southern Flinders (2009-2017) | 9 |
| 108 | Charlie Arbon | Mundoora (1951-1955), Port Broughton (1956-1958). | 8 |
| Fred Stigwood | Solomontown (1942, 1946-1947, 1949-1950, 1954-1956). | 8 |
| Bob Clayton | West Whyalla (1976-1977), Millicent (1978-1979), Proprietary (1980-1983). | 8 |
| J J Davoren | Eudunda (1905-1907, 1909-1913). | 8 |
| Mike Weatherald | Stirling (1971-1974), Heathfield Aldgate (1975), Onkaparinga Valley (1976- 1977), Mount Lofty (1988). (Heathfield Aldgate United) | 8 |
| Mick Fitzgerald | Port Noarlunga (1972-1974, 1982), Loxton (1976-1977), Mount Compass (1979-1980). | 8 |
| Kerry Hamilton | Port (1976-1978), Gladstone Combine (1981-1982), Bute (1983), Wunkar (1996-1997). (Port (Bulldogs)) | 8 |
| Peter Kempe | Tailem Bend (1984-1985), Mypolonga (1986-1989), Imperial - RMFL (1993- 1994). (Imperial (RM)) | 8 |
| Malcolm Hill | Berri (1965-1969, 1975-1977). | 8 |
| Trevor Hill | Mypolonga (1990-1994), Lobethal (1995-1997). | 8 |
| Barry Walker | Beachport (1962-1963), Mount Burr (1964-1966), Hatherleigh (1967-1969). (Mount Burr United) | 8 |
| F Jones | Kangarilla (1968-1975). | 8 |
| Lothar Scholz | United (1963), Wudinna (1967-1969), Minnipa (1972, 1976), Warramboo (1975). | 8 |
| Warren Boxer | Wisanger (1958-1961, 1963-1966). | 8 |
| Steven Lewis | Yankalilla (1997-2001, 2007-2009). | 8 |
| Max Bell | Cleve (1979-1982), Loxton (1983-1984), Mount Compass (1986-1987). | 8 |
| Adrian Jolly | Loxton (1953-1954, 1960-1962), Loxton North (1968-1970). | 8 |
| Justin Duffy | Orroroo (1999-2000, 2005-2010). | 8 |
| Michael Durdin | East Murray (2003-2006), Brown's Well (2007), Wunkar (2013-2015). (Brown’s Well) | 8 |
| Shayne Mitchell | Langhorne Creek (2001-2004), Encounter Bay (2009), United Eagles (2011), Hornridge (2014-2015). (Callington United Eagles) | 8 |
| Mark Thomson | Blyth Snowtown, (2005-2008), Two Wells (2011-2014). | 8 |
| Rian Nelson | Barossa Districts (2008-2009), Hamley Bridge (2010-2011), Wallaroo (2012-2014), Bridgewater Callington (2017). | 8 |
| Leigh Capewell | Nangwarry (1999-2001), South Gambier (2002-2004), Port MacDonnell (2015-2016). | 8 |
| Geoff Lokan | Jervois (1962-1964), Tailem Bend (1969-1971, 1974-1975). | 8 |
| Roger James | Barossa Districts (2010-2015), Southern Saints (2016-2017) | 8 |
| 133 | Simon Johnson | Birdwood (2003-2005), Angaston (2007-2008), Macclesfield (2009-2010). | 7 |
| Peter Jeffery | Reynella (1973-1976, 1983), Port Noarlunga (1981), Myponga (1983). | 7 |
| Martin Leslie | Nuriootpa (2004-2005), United Yeelanna (2006-2007), Boston (2008-2010). (Nuriootpa Rovers) | 7 |
| Dennis Murch | Bordertown (1968-1974). | 7 |
| Andrew Jenner | Cowell (1990), Cleve (1995-1999, 2011). | 7 |
| Doug Murphy | Tumby Bay (1963, 1971-1974, 1989-1990). | 7 |
| Bob Fisher | Berri (1972-1974), Barmera Monash (1978-1981). | 7 |
| Malcolm Williams | Mount Barker (1996-2002). | 7 |
| Russ Laird | Kaniva (1950-1956). | 7 |
| Stan Jones | Glencoe (1954-1960). | 7 |
| Colin Thompson | Central Augusta (1974-1975), Noarlunga (1979-1980), Encounter Bay (1981-1983). | 7 |
| Kevin Maddern | Loxton (1989-1990, 1998-1999), Moorook Kingston (1991-1993). | 7 |
| Jim Abdulla | Gerard (1974-1975, 1977-1979, 1981, 1983). | 7 |
| Sam Mahony | Jervois (2008-2009), Brighton (2011-2012), Peake (2013-2015). (Peake & District FC) | 7 |
| Steve Wildman | Cowell (1995-1996, 1999-2000, 2007-2009). | 7 |
| Tony Higgins | Tumby Bay (1985-1988, 1992, 1994, 2001). | 7 |
| Don Hannaford | Riverton (1965-1966, 1968, 1970-1973). | 7 |
| Geoff Schell | Kapunda (1979-1981, 1985-1988). | 7 |
| Keith Earl | Mallala (2005-2011). | 7 |
| Lyall Ackland | Mintaro Manoora (1969-1971, 1974, 1978-1980). | 7 |
| Kelvin Bailey | Ngallo (1987-1988, 1998-1999), Murrayville (1995-1997). | 7 |
| Bill Williams | Warramboo (1953, 1955-1958, 1960-1961). | 7 |
| Dick Oakey | West Augusta (1967-1973). | 7 |
| Brendan Kluska | Auburn (1967), South Clare (1968-1969, 1976), Lock (1988-1990). | 7 |
| Wayne Fromm | East Murray (1989-1991), Blanchetown Swan Reach (1992-1994, 1999). | 7 |
| Cameron Redden | BMW (2009-2011), Central Whyalla (2012-2013), South Augusta (2014- 2015). (BMW Lions) | 7 |
| Gary Lazarus | East Gambier (1972-1976), Millicent (1980-1981). | 7 |
| Ken Tucker | Kapunda (1972-1974), Goolwa (1975), Tanunda (1976-1978). | 7 |
| Rory Livingstone | McLaren Flat (1994-1995), Kangarilla (1997-1998, 2001-2003). | 7 |
| Wayne Potter | Willunga (1973-1974, 1978, 1981-1982), McLaren Flat (1975-1976). | 7 |
| Bob Bishop | West Whyalla (1949-1950), South Augusta (1953-1954), Port (1955-1957) (Port (Bulldogs)) | 7 |
