| # | Club | Period | Years | League |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eyre United | 1963-2017 | 55 | Great Flinders |
| 2 | Heywood | 1964-2011 | 47 | Western Border |
| Meningie | 1954-2001 | 47 | River Murray | |
| 4 | Mannum | 1960-2003 | 43 | Torrens Valley/River Murray |
| Kybybolite | 1975-2017 | 43 | Kowree Naracoorte/KNTFL | |
| 6 | Moonta | 1963-2005 | 42 | Yorke Valley/Yorke Peninsula |
| 7 | Wunkar | 1977-2017 | 41 | Riverland Independent |
| 8 | Geranium | 1946-1951, 1958-1990 | 39 | Lameroo & Districts |
| 9 | West Gambier | 1972-2009 | 38 | Western Border |
| 10 | Border Downs | 1955-1992 | 38 | River Murray |
| 11 | Macclesfield | 1981-2017 | 37 | Hills (Div II)/Southern/Hills Country |
| 12 | Mount Compass | 1980-2016 | 37 | Great Southern |
| 13 | Wandearah | 1940, 1946-1979 | 35 | Broughton |
| Lucindale | 1971-2005 | 34 | Kowree Naracoorte/KNTFL | |
| Rudall | 1978-2011 | 34 | County Jervois/Eastern Eyre | |
| Cummins | 1964-1996 | 34 | Great Flinders | |
| Owen | 1932-1938, 1946-1973 | 34 | Adelaide Plains | |
| Kingston | 1984-2017 | 34 | Kowree Naracoorte/KNTFL | |
| Gumeracha | 1984-2017 | 34 | Hills (Div. II)/Hills Country | |
| 20 | Myponga/Mypo-Sellicks (Myponga Sellicks) | 1984-2017 | 34 | Great Southern |
| Waikerie | 1937-1939, 1945-1974 | 33 | Upper Murray/Riverland | |
| 22 | Bridgewater | 1982-2014 | 33 | Hills (Div. II)/Hills (Div. I)/Hills Central |
| Morphett Vale | 1938-1940, 1946-1977 | 32 | Southern | |
| Reynella | 1957-1982 | 32 | Southern | |
| 25 | Carpa | 1920-1940, 1946-1956 | 32 | Franklin Harbour |
| Warramboo | 1956-1986 | 31 | Le Hunte | |
| 27 | Parilla | 1946-1976 | 31 | Lameroo & District |
| 28 | Minnipa | 1958-1987 | 30 | Le Hunte |
| North Whyalla | 1980-2008 | 29 | Whyalla | |
| Kapunda | 1975-2003 | 29 | Barossa & Light/Barossa Light & Gawler | |
| Gawler Central | 1954-1982 | 29 | Gawler & District | |
| Coorabie | 1925-1940, 1946-1958 | 29 | Far West FA | |
| East Gambier | 1988-1929 | 29 | Western Border | |
| 34 | Eudunda | 1982-2009 | 28 | North Eastern / Barossa & Light |
| Elliston | 1968-1994 | 28 | Le Hunte/Mid West | |
| Nangwarry | 1965-1992 | 28 | Mid South East | |
| Onkaparinga | 1919-1940, 1946-1950 | 28 | Hills/Mount Lofty | |
| Ports | 1989-2016 | 28 | Eastern Eyre |